First thing I would ask is how many rpms do you want to turn? Are you loooking to get down around 5k or want to stay up around 6k? Without knowing what engine you have and where it makes horsepower it will be difficult to recommend what size prop you need to try. As for the vibration, a 2 blade will vibrate some. You said your old prop was a 2 blade so I am assuming that the new prop vibrates a LOT more than it did. If the boat runs smooth with it then your prop probably needs some balance work. Bottom line what prop you need depends on what you want the boat to do. If you want more more speed you need more pitch. If you go up in pitch and the rpms go down further than you want then you need to look at a similar pitch in a smaller diameter. Tell us how many rpms are running, how many rpms you want to run, what pitch you have and then I'm sure someone can give you a better idea of what prop to try next.