Definately somethin' haywire with the pump, if she spins to 4500 and no-go-no-more. You cant see what's happening between the aft edge of the imp. and the bowl, without pulling the bowl. Open 'er up, my guess is there's something in there. Towel, rope,cat, rocks, something.
Also, Make sure the reverse bucket is going all the way up, you said the cable broke, Could be something here too.
fog