The reason for that is the clearance between the body and the plunger, the soft one has more clearance(Cheap Taywan shit) and that will show up after running hard and the oil gets hot, when you come to an idle you will have a lifter clatter!. The Sealed Power is a good lifter and have tighter tolerance, I've never had a problem with one of their lifters. If you bought "Summit's" lifters you may have a misspackaged deal, I would send them back and get all the right ones!... My .02.....